Conversions, as they happen in India, are not only forced. The other major reason for conversions is poverty and illiteracy and of course, social oppression.
Gandhi too was against conversion of people in these circumstances, and my reasons are the same as his. Converting people in these circumstances is simply a way of taking advantage of their travails.
Moreover, it is cheating them. Why do Dalit Christians want reservations? Why did K. Stalin's film "India Untouched" talk about untouchability among Christians and Muslims too?
In such a situation, dont you think those converting poor people for the following reasons >> poverty >> untouchability >> illiteracy are cheating them with false promises of a better life? Gandhi said the same thing.
Secondly, lets face it, while every religion wants conversions TO it, no religion likes conversions FROM it. Apostasy would not be punishable by death in some religions if this were not so. Conversions in this sense, create tensions, or increase them.
Thirdly, the very act of changing a religion should involve you considering the merits of the two given religions and deciding what convinces you more.
This can be ideally achieved only through means of a proper debate between scholars of both religions face to face. Listening to the debate, the version you find most convincing, choose that.
I'm not against conversions per se, if done in the right manner, where the consideration is not money, not a perceived improvement in life (which is often false promise), but a genuine philosophical consideration.
The man who views the world at 50 the same as he did at 20 has wasted 30 years of his life.
Muhammad Ali......
I m A very sTraiGht 4ward Person As weLL As I knw bout mASeLf ...I look at things in a way that no other person looks that makes me different from other pople..
The idea of conversion is really a pathetic & insecure act by some insane groups...
ReplyDeleteConversions, as they happen in India, are not only forced. The other major reason for conversions is poverty and illiteracy and of course, social oppression.
ReplyDeleteGandhi too was against conversion of people in these circumstances, and my reasons are the same as his. Converting people in these circumstances is simply a way of taking advantage of their travails.
Moreover, it is cheating them. Why do Dalit Christians want reservations? Why did K. Stalin's film "India Untouched" talk about untouchability among Christians and Muslims too?
In such a situation, dont you think those converting poor people for the following reasons
>> poverty
>> untouchability
>> illiteracy
are cheating them with false promises of a better life? Gandhi said the same thing.
Secondly, lets face it, while every religion wants conversions TO it, no religion likes conversions FROM it. Apostasy would not be punishable by death in some religions if this were not so. Conversions in this sense, create tensions, or increase them.
Thirdly, the very act of changing a religion should involve you considering the merits of the two given religions and deciding what convinces you more.
This can be ideally achieved only through means of a proper debate between scholars of both religions face to face. Listening to the debate, the version you find most convincing, choose that.
I'm not against conversions per se, if done in the right manner, where the consideration is not money, not a perceived improvement in life (which is often false promise), but a genuine philosophical consideration.